πŸ“ Atlanta
β˜• Coffee-fueled ✊ Feminist β™“ Pisces 🌱 Vegan since 2016
A cozy desk scene with a steaming mug of coffee, an open journal, and soft golden fairy lights against a dark navy backdrop

What you'll find here

  • Feminist essays and social-justice commentary
  • Mental-health and personal-growth stories
  • Astrology deep-dives and zodiac positivity
  • Music, pop-culture, and 90s-alternative love
  • Rabbit care and life with Florence 🐰
Podcast episodes
Coffee with Katiee
Newsletter
Your Weekly Love Letter
πŸŽ™ Listen to the Podcast β†’
  • Latest post: Is Your Rabbit Having Panic Attacks? Mine is too. (November 25, 2020)
  • Also recent: Miley Cyrus is this Generation's Stevie Nicks, and That's On Feminism (November 6, 2020)
  • Featured: 8 Black Women Lightworkers To Follow Immediately

I'm a Feminist Who Loves Romance Novels: Notes on the Paradox

There is a particular embarrassment I have owned since my early twenties: I am a feminist who reads romance novels at one in the morning, under the doona, with a long black from the corner shop going cold on the bedside table. I read about doctors with vows and brooding dukes, about a heroine whose competence is treated as an obstacle to be charmed out of the way, and I do it while thinking about wage gaps, the gender pay gap data, and the fact that Australia's domestic violence statistics still make me want to throw something.

The contradiction gets called out regularly. Say you love romance novels in feminist company and someone reaches for the smug version of the argument: that the genre is reactionary, that loving it means secretly wanting to be owned, that every happily-ever-after is a small surrender of the self.

But I have read a lot of feminist theory, and I have read a lot of romance, and I have never once been convinced that enjoyment requires agreement. Plenty of people love a Western and know what the West is. The interesting question is not whether I am allowed to like the genre. It is what exactly the liking is doing to me, and where the line sits between a pleasure that challenges me and a pleasure that quietly undoes me.

This is the kind of slow, honest argument I keep trying to make room for on Life Starts With Coffee, through the Coffee with Katiee podcast and the weekly newsletter, where the posts about bisexuality, eating-disorder recovery, anxiety and healing sit alongside the astrology, the music, and the rabbit care. The genre has never been the problem. The silence about it has been.

The badge and the bookmark

The most obvious tension is that romance is the only genre that insists, for several hundred pages, that love is worth having. It is the genre of the chosen life: someone sees you, asks, and waits. For a feminist reader that matters, because the fantasy being sold is not really about a man. It is about being wanted on purpose.

The problem is that the genre also handed us a very specific template for that wanting. The domineering stranger, the heroine who does not know her own mind until someone tells her, the marriage proposal as a reward for endurance, the career as a phase to be outgrown. In 2024 Australia, where same-sex marriage has been legal since 2017, that template reads less like a natural law than a habit nobody has thought to change. The ending I want is the ending my country already gives me, and the books still insist on the older version of it.

There is a second tension, quieter: the feminist who reads romance is assumed to have stopped reading. We treat the paperback in the tote bag as evidence of a kind of failure, and we treat confession as proof that the failure is real. I have never found that useful. A feminist who loves romance novels is not less informed than one who does not. She is more likely to have a hard time explaining why she keeps going back, and more likely to have thought harder about why it feels like coming home.

Where the formula came from

The genre's history is not a feminist history, and pretending otherwise flattens it. Romance was, for a long time, the pulp that got policed. New Zealand banned Patricia Robins' Goodnight Sweetheart in 1956 and kept it banned for more than a decade, and Australian reviewers were famously active about condemning the paperbacks that flooded postwar shelves. Australian police cracked down on the circulating libraries where dog-eared Mills and Boon titles were swapped between neighbours, and the lending-library librarian of my childhood looked at a romance novel the way you would look at something confiscated.

So when the feminist readers of the era reached for romance, they were reaching for something the state had already decided was mildly indecent. That history explains part of the guilty pleasure and all of the secrecy. It also explains why the form stayed so long on the old template: the commercial reward for a formula that readers already loved was to refine it, not reinvent it.

And that refinement has happened. Contemporary romance is far more likely to give the heroine a career she keeps, a friend she survives on, a body she is allowed to have opinions about, and a sexual scene where both people are clearly enjoying themselves. The genre has been quietly improving under the pressure of readers who wanted more, which is one of the better arguments for reading anything at all.

Last year I sat in on a session about art, protest and pleasure at the Women in Music Atlanta edition of the conference and heard the question asked out loud in a room full of women: does pleasure need permission? It is a question I have heard in Australian feminist spaces too, usually aimed at people who admit to reading romance or watching true crime, as though admitting to pleasure is the confession rather than the question.

Consent in the pages, consent in the statute book

Australian law has recently made the boring, concrete rules around consent and intoxication very clear. Victoria's Consent to Care Act 2024 put consent for intimate medical procedures into statute. New South Wales amended the Crimes Act 1900 to create a specific offence of spiking, so that slipping something into a drink is no longer a footnote but a chargeable act, and Queensland's Criminal Code carries a comparable provision under section 419A. The age of consent was raised to seventeen in New South Wales and to eighteen in Victoria.

The law does all the emotional work that old romance novels often refused to do. It says: no means no, incapacity means no, and the fact that you bought the drinks is not an exchange. It also says that the way forward is to believe women when they say something happened, which is precisely the thing the old romance formula got wrong for decades, where a heroine's protest was usually a sign of being overcome rather than being heard.

The culture is catching up too, unevenly. Australia still has the share-house party where the drinks come from a shared bottle and nobody checks the glass, the servo run at midnight, the tradie barbecue where alcohol does the socialising. Legislation moves faster than habit, and habit is what the genre is made of.

What the pages promise next to what the law requires

Below is the comparison I keep coming back to when someone tells me the genre is simply bad for me. The left column is the older, more durable template. The middle column is what Australian law and current practice actually say. The right column is where I land after reading both.

In the pages On the street and in the statute book Where I land
The hero takes, the heroine protests "No" means no; intoxication is no; the Crimes Act 1900 s 66A makes spiking its own offence in NSW The protest trope is a historical artefact, and it takes the fantasy of being asked to survive it
A party, a drink, a predator Shared bottles, midnight servo runs, and a Queensland Criminal Code provision on drink spiking Law drew the line the fiction should have drawn decades ago
The proposal as the payoff Marriage Act amended in 2017 so any two people can marry The ending I want is already legally mine; the books just have not caught up
The career as a phase to outgrow Paid parental leave, superannuation splits, unpaid care work, the arbitration process A fantasy of being supported is a luxury plenty of readers never have, so I read it as longing, not as advice
Youth, thinness, fixing yourself Body image pressure, diet marketing on the supermarket shelves, long waiting lists for mental health care I want the emotional arc, not the body count, and the arc is about being believed

Read that row by row and something interesting appears. In every column where the fiction is worst, the law has already caught the behaviour and named it as harm. Which means the discomfort I feel reading those old tropes is not nostalgia for a good old day. It is a small, private grief for a world that needed those rules written down.

Comfort, escape and the autonomy of the reader

I read romance for the same reason I read on the tram to work: to be somewhere else for a while. Anxiety is not fixed by argument, at least not mine; it is managed by small, predictable pleasures that leave no mess. The comfort reread is a real technique. The right book at the right hour can lower the volume in your head, and I do not think it is a feminist failure to use it.

It is the autonomy question that keeps me honest, though. I found the same lesson waiting for me in what rabbit care and autonomy means about handling a frightened animal in your arms: you open the door, you do not push the rabbit through it. That is also what I want from a book. I want to be able to put it down. I want the ending to be something I chose rather than something the genre decided for me, and I want the heroine to arrive at her own life, not to be handed one.

So the standard I have settled on is this: the fantasy has to leave me more capable than it found me. Does this book ask me to be smaller than I am? Does it treat a woman's no as a negotiation? Does it want me to believe that being chosen by a man is the same as being loved by one? If the answer is yes, I close it. If the answer is no, I read it three times and complain about the cover art.

Reading the genre without keeping the contradiction

Some practical things I have learned, mostly by arguing with friends in pubs across Melbourne and Sydney rather than by sorting it out on my own.

What stays with me is not a verdict but a habit. I read romance novels the way I read everything else: with my eyes open, checking the parts that flatter me and the parts that are trying to teach me something false. I do not need the genre to be innocent. I need it to be legible.

And I need to be honest about what I actually want, which is a life with someone in it, chosen by me, in a country that finally stopped arguing about whether I get to choose. That want is not a weakness in my politics. It is the reason the politics exist. The contradiction was never really a contradiction at all. It was just the shape of a feminist who wants a life that includes joy, including the kind of joy that arrives in paperback form at one in the morning with a cold long black and a bookmark halfway through.

Pleasure, read carefully, is not a betrayal of anything.

What's on the site

Podcast
Coffee with Katiee β€” launched November 12, 2018. Episodes cover feminism, astrology, and energy tarot readings. Available on Anchor.fm.
Healing Services
Astrology chart readings and energy tarot readings available for booking.
Merch
Branded and themed merchandise featuring feminist and lifestyle designs.
Newsletter
Your Weekly Love Letter β€” a weekly email with podcast updates, blog posts, and exclusive content.
Portfolio
A collection of Katiee's published writing and creative work, including pieces written for other publications.
Blog Highlights
On Being Bisexual (Nov 2019), My Eating Disorder (May 2019), Women in Music: Atlanta Edition (Jul 2019), What I LOVE About Each Zodiac Sign (Jun 2019), and more.
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…
Community voices
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…
"Katiee's writing on bisexuality and mental health is so refreshingly honest. It feels like talking to a friend who really gets it."
β€” A blog reader
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…
"The zodiac positivity post genuinely made my day. Finally someone spreading love instead of hate during Cancer season."
β€” Astrology enthusiast
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…
"Her SAAM post was brave and necessary. Katiee uses her platform to speak up about things that matter."
β€” Feminist community member
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…
"The rabbit panic-attack post was a lifesaver. There's so little info out there β€” thank you for sharing your experience with Florence."
β€” Fellow bunny parent